The Senate Circus

Written by Hank on . Posted in Uncategorized

A very important drama is playing out in the Senate this week and it’s not the Mike Duffy trial that the media is so obsessed with. It is actually playing out in a Senate chamber where the Finance Committee is listening to submissions by various parties on Bill C 377.

This partisan and deeply flawed piece of legislation, which will force unions to make public their expenses over $5,000 (among other requirements), is now before the Senate for the second time in its original, unamended form. When first brought to the Senate, members of all parties  acknowledged that the bill has serious flaws and runs the risk of running afoul of the Privacy Act, breaching lawyer-client privilege, and even facing constitutional challenge. The bill was significantly amended by senators on both sides of the aisle in a non-partisan fashion and sent back to the Commons. Now it’s back in the Senate, exactly the same as it was when first presented.  

Taxes and Doing the Right Thing

Written by Hank on . Posted in Health care

Nobody likes to pay taxes, but sometimes that is the only way to do the right thing. Like it or not, looking after the frail seniors in this province is our combined responsibility as citizens. Long term care funding per resident in Ontario is 15 percent lower than the national average.

Ontario has been told about this underfunding in study after study for over 20 years. It is acknowledged as a critical problem by every politician on both sides of the aisle, and yet nothing ever happens to seriously address it.

The Value of Partnerships

Written by Hank on . Posted in Uncategorized

I had a colleague who was famous for saying, “You build relationships or policies in good times for bad.” There is a lot of wisdom in that.

Labour relations is a lot like any human relationship. It has its ups and downs and you have to be committed to working at it. CLAC has always championed a partnership approach to labour relations. This has causes some union leaders to accuse us of naiveté, or of even being outright traitors to the working class. Interestingly, when you speak one-on-one to good union reps of any union, they will tell you that they trade on good relationships all the time to achieve goals for their membership.

The Death of Worker Choice

Written by Hank on . Posted in Uncategorized

The recently elected Liberal government of Nova Scotia has just passed legislation that arbitrarily reduces the number of healthcare bargaining units in the province from 50 to 4. Sounds simple and efficient right? It will cut the number of bargaining sessions, thus saving time and money. The problem is that the freedom of choice of these workers has just been destroyed forever! How?

First, it will result in bargaining units of such massive size that it will be logistically impossible to mobilize support to try to bring in a different union.

Second, if an intrepid individual who felt disenfranchised or abused by their union were to challenge their union, they would face the massive power and legal machinery of the union alone. No chance of success.

Third, if a group of employees got together and approached another union with the resources to displace a non-functioning union, they would be stopped by the no-raid pact that most of traditional labour has agreed to, so workers are left with no viable options.

“Johnny, Git ‘Ur Gun” – When labour relations resembles a war zone

Written by Hank on . Posted in Labour relations, Unions

There’s been a lot of talk lately about the weapons that American police forces use and the way in which they use them. Remember the scenes from Ferguson, Mo., where police, looking more like soldiers than cops, marched through the streets, armed with army-surplus sniper rifles while wearing camo? Many worry that American police now rely more on their weapons and armour rather than honest detective work or dialogue to resolve problems.

Now, I am not against our police having weapons. There are times when they are needed. But they shouldn’t be the go-to solution for every crisis, and they don’t need to be military-grade.

Use-of-force must be in line with the situation and should always be a last resort. Otherwise, innocent civilians can get caught in the crossfire, and distrust and disrespect for the police grows.

The attitudes of “the person with the biggest gun wins,” and “shoot first, negotiate later,” are present in labour relations as well. Unions tend to hold strike votes before they even start negotiations, and companies don’t hesitate to lockout workers if the union doesn’t cede to their demands—no matter how unreasonable. Just ask former Electro-Motive workers in London, who were locked out and lost their jobs when Caterpillar, the parent company, moved Electro-Motive to Indiana.

Employers often aren’t prepared to negotiate until there is a stick hanging over their heads, and sometimes they refuse to allow neutral third parties to resolve disputes. And neither side seems prepared to give up any power.

Work stoppages should be used only as a last resort after all attempts of negotiation have failed. Because in a strike or lockout, no one wins.

Animated Social Media Icons Powered by Acurax Wordpress Development Company
Visit Us On TwitterVisit Us On FacebookVisit Us On YoutubeVisit Us On LinkedinCheck Our Feed